RCG Starboard Advisors, LLC, an affiliate of Ramius LLC (collectively,
"Ramius”), today announced that RiskMetrics Group ("RiskMetrics” or
"RMG”), the leading independent proxy voting advisory and risk
management consulting firm to the global financial community, has
recommended that shareholders of Orthofix International N.V. ("Orthofix”
or the "Company”) (Nasdaq: OFIX) vote on Ramius’ Gold proxy card to
elect Ramius nominees J. Michael Egan, Peter A. Feld and Charles T.
Orsatti to the ten member Board of Directors of Orthofix and to remove
current Chairman of the Board James F. Gero, and directors Peter J.
Hewett and Walter P. Von Wartburg at a Special General Meeting of
Shareholders on April 2, 2009. Ramius is the beneficial owner of
approximately 5.7% of the Company’s outstanding common shares.
Ramius Partner Jeffrey C. Smith stated, "RiskMetrics' support provides
significant validation to our concerns about the current Orthofix Board.
With over 1700 proxy advisory clients worldwide and extensive experience
in providing voting advice to institutional clients since 1986,
particularly in proxy contests, RiskMetrics is adept at identifying the
real issues of concern to shareholders. They clearly recognize that the
lack of accountability by the Orthofix Board has directly contributed to
the destruction of nearly $500 million of shareholder value and that the
election of new directors is required.”
Continued Smith, "In its analysis, RiskMetrics pointedly captures why
immediate change at the Board level is required. RiskMetrics states,
‘Without commenting on the qualification of incumbent nominees, we
recommend shareholders vote for the removal of James Gero (director
since 1995), Walter Wartburg (director since 2004) and Peter Hewett
(director since 1992). We note that the three incumbent nominees have
been on the board since the Blackstone acquisition and have presided
over a period of sustained underperformance.’”
Added Smith, "Given the significant strategic, financial and operational
issues facing Orthofix, that are a direct result of numerous failures by
the Board and management, the shareholders cannot trust the Board, as
currently constituted, to oversee the Company’s restructuring. Instead,
this Board needs new, independent directors, not tied to the mistakes of
the past, with the fortitude, skill sets and experience necessary to ask
the tough questions, maintain accountability over management and ensure
that all decisions at the Board level are made with shareholders’ best
interests in mind.”
Concluded Smith, "We urge our fellow shareholders to send a message to
the current Board by voting their GOLD proxy card today to elect Ramius’
independent nominees who are firmly committed to the future success of
Orthofix.”
Excerpts of RiskMetrics Analysis & Recommendation
Conclusion:
-
"Orthofix’s share price and financial performance have suffered since
Blackstone’s acquisition in FY06. The company’s share price has lagged
its peer group, while its financial performance has deteriorated due
to sustained operating losses at the Blackstone division.”
-
"Notwithstanding management’s favorable outlook for Blackstone, we
note that the company took a $289.5 (87% of $330 million acquisition
price) million impairment charge for Blackstone in FY08. This we
believe suggests that the acquisition is unlikely to yield the desired
results, even if the turnaround strategy works.”
-
"As such, given the company’s sustained underperformance relative to
its peer group since the Blackstone acquisition, we believe that the
board could benefit from greater shareholder representation. Though
Ramius is seeking minority representation (four out of ten board
seats) and has made a valid case for change, based on our review of
the dissident nominees, we recommend shareholders vote FOR the
election of Peter Feld, Michael Egan and Charles Orsatti.”
Orthofix share price performance
-
"Our analysis indicates that Orthofix performed in line with its peer
group over the 1, 3 and 5 year periods for the period ending July 30,
2006, just prior to the acquisition of Blackstone. Since the
acquisition announcement on Aug. 7, 2006, however, the company’s share
price has declined 61.6% versus an average 32.2% for the peer group.
-
"We believe such significant share price underperformance to its peer
group, lends credence to Ramius’ argument that the acquisition has not
been value creative for shareholders.”
Orthofix operating performance
-
"Orthofix’s poor share price performance since Blackstone acquisition
could be attributed to the negative impact of Blackstone on overall
financial performance. Our analysis indicates that not only has
Blackstone’s revenue growth lagged other business segments, but also
its operating losses have negatively impacted the company’s overall
profitability.”
-
"Moreover, sustained losses at the Blackstone division have affected
company’s debt coverage ratios, which likely caused the company to
amend its credit facility in Sept 2008. Pursuant to the amended terms,
the effective interest rate on the $290 million term loan increased to
LIBOR + 4.5% from LIBOR + 1.75% previously.”
Analyst estimates vs. mgmt guidance
-
"We looked at management’s historical track record of earnings
guidance to assess if the market is likely to believe in its
expectation of achieving positive operating profit for Blackstone in
4QFY09. This we believe, is important given Blackstone has adversely
impacted the company’s overall profitability and thereby share price
performance.”
-
"Based on Reuters Knowledge database, we note that over the last 10
quarters (beginning 3QFY06), the company missed its revenue guidance 6
times and GAAP EPS guidance four times. On an annual basis, the
company has missed revenue guidance twice in the last three years
(though the percentage miss is small) and GAAP EPS in all the three
years.”
On Ramius’ nominees
-
"Regarding dissident nominees, we note that although Peter Feld has
the least company/sector experience, he represents a significant
shareholder and as such his interests are likely to be aligned with
other shareholders.”
-
"Among other dissident nominees, we support Michael Egan and Charles
Orsatti for their sector/industry experience. Additionally, we note
that the company had previously been willing to interview both Mr.
Egan and Orsatti for board seats.”
-
And though the company has raised concerns about Ramius’ desire to
quickly sell the Blackstone division, we note that such a decision
would require the support of the entire or at least majority of the
board members, and that Ramius and its nominees would only represent a
minority, if elected. This coupled with the fiduciary obligations of
directors should ensure that dissident nominees act in the best
interest of all shareholders.”
Please visit www.ShareholdersForOrthofix.com
for more information on the upcoming special meeting and to view Ramius’
solicitation materials in connection with the meeting. A copy of all
proxy materials and shareholder communications are available on the
website.
About Ramius LLC
Ramius LLC is a registered investment advisor that manages assets in a
variety of alternative investment strategies. Ramius LLC is
headquartered in New York with offices located in London, Tokyo, Hong
Kong, Munich, and Vienna.