Rohm and Haas Company (NYSE: ROH) today issued the following statement:
We understand that this is a difficult environment for the chemical
industry. However, the difficult conditions in the chemical industry and
financial markets commenced before Dow agreed to acquire Rohm and Haas
and were widely expected to worsen at the time we entered into the
transaction. Therefore, we insisted in our merger agreement that Dow
assume both of these risks, rather than the Rohm and Haas shareholders.
Dow should honor its obligations and close the transaction.
There are multiple steps Dow can and should immediately take to reduce
its dependence on the bridge loan and secure the financial strength of
the merged company. We are convinced that Dow has the ability to close
the deal and succeed.
Yesterday, Rohm and Haas's Board of Directors sent the following letter
to the Dow Board of Directors detailing actions Dow should take to
obtain the financing and honor its contract:
|
|
|
Letter sent via fax by Rohm and Haas Company
|
|
February 2, 2009
|
|
|
|
The Board of Directors
|
|
The Dow Chemical Company
|
|
2030 Dow Center
|
|
Midland, Michigan 48674
|
|
|
Ladies and Gentlemen:
The members of our Board of Directors wish to convey to each of you our
extreme disappointment at Dow's failure to honor fundamental and
indisputable obligations to our company. Our board selected Dow as the
winning bidder based on the contract it signed and on our regard for
your company. The behavior we have encountered has confounded us:
without claiming any legal justification, Dow refused to close the Rohm
and Haas merger as required by the merger agreement between our
companies.
We understand that you were disappointed by the K-Dow situation.
However, when Dow signed the merger agreement, it did not have a binding
deal with Petroleum Industries Company, and neither our merger nor your
financing was conditioned in any way on a K-Dow deal. Dow, not Rohm and
Haas, took the risk that the K-Dow deal would not close. And Dow, not
Rohm and Haas, took the risk that the difficult economic climate that
both companies already faced in July 2008 would worsen.
When K-Dow collapsed, the reasonable commercial approach would have been
to call and explain that there was a problem and set forth your proposed
plan for addressing that problem. We specifically requested that you do
this. To this day we have not
received a substantive explanation
of what Dow is doing to address the impact of the failure of the K-Dow
deal. Instead we learned, after the fact, of prohibited ex-parte
contacts to regulators made by Dow senior executives and counsel. These
activities and Dow's attempts to claim that they were somehow permitted
are not worthy of a great company like Dow.
Nevertheless, we have tried to understand Dow's difficulties and develop
a path to a satisfactory resolution. We therefore asked repeatedly that
Dow's senior executives provide an explanation of Dow's approach to
resolving this situation and completing the merger on the agreed terms.
To that end, our Chairman and General Counsel participated in meetings
with their Dow counterparts which we hoped would further our evaluation.
In order to make those meetings productive, we asked that your top
financial executives, as well as our financial and legal advisors, be
present in meetings about your proposed financing plan. When that
request was denied, we asked that our advisors and financial executives
be available nearby - a request that was also denied. In fact, Dow's
executives' reaction to our desire to bring as much expertise as
possible to assist us and them in addressing the current difficulty was
to refuse to meet in our executive offices.
When we asked on many occasions for a specific plan, we were told, in
different ways, that Dow had many "balls in the air." When we asked for
a specific proposal from Dow concerning the amount of time Dow wanted to
delay the closing - a concept we were willing to accept if we could
protect our shareholders in the interim - your Chairman instead sent an
email indicating, that, if we waited until June 30, Dow would then be
better positioned to decide if it would honor its obligation to close.
This "offer" constituted the culmination of hours of meetings on three
separate occasions.
We urge the directors of Dow to take control of this situation. You are
the individual overseers of Dow's obligation to comply with the merger
agreement. If Dow is in the terrible financial condition that your
Chairman suggests, we do not know how you could have paid the January
30, 2009 cash dividend of almost $400 million. We certainly do not see
how Dow and its directors, consistent with their obligations under the
merger agreement and Delaware General Corporation Law § 170, can declare
any further dividends at this point.
Dow agreed in the merger agreement to take "all action necessary"
to obtain the financing for the merger. This obligation is clear and
unambiguous. It is not limited to actions that are on terms
commercially favorable to Dow or indeed limited in any other manner.
Dow also agreed not to take any action that is reasonably likely to
prevent, impair or materially delay Dow's ability to obtain the
financing.
Accordingly, we request that Dow pursue the steps listed on Annex A to
this letter in order to obtain the financing for the merger (if
financing is not currently available to you) and advise us promptly and
frequently of the status thereof.
When we embarked on this transaction, we certainly did not anticipate
being a plaintiff in a massive litigation. That is certainly not the
Rohm and Haas way. We commenced litigation because from a practical
standpoint we were given no viable choice. We await your reply.
|
|
|
Sincerely,
|
|
Board of Directors
|
|
Rohm and Haas Company
|
|
|
|
Signed:
|
|
|
SANDRA O. MOOSE
|
|
|
|
|
Director
|
|
|
|
|
|
Annex A
-
Cease the declaration or payment of any cash dividend, other than a
penny per share, and commit to do so in the future to the extent
necessary to satisfy lenders and rating agencies.
-
Actively pursue asset sales of Dow's and Rohm and Haas's businesses
and divisions. We request that you contact all potentially interested
parties, including your competitors, for each and everyone of these
diverse businesses. Sales of our assets would, of course, occur at or
after the closing of the merger, and we, of course, would fully
cooperate with you.
-
Pursue all options to raise equity in private or public markets,
including underwritten and private placements and rights offerings,
and all forms of securities, including common stock, warrants and
convertible securities.
-
Pursue all options to raise long term debt in private or public
markets, including underwritten and private placements, and all forms
of securities, including secured and convertible securities.
-
Pursue all options to extend the existing $13 billion revolving credit
agreement or to seek waivers thereunder or amendments thereto to the
extent required.
-
Take all other actions requested by any rating agency in connection
with obtaining financing for the merger.
-
Evaluate and pursue all available financing options in the event that
Dow is unable to retain its investment grade credit rating.
-
Bear your obligations under the merger agreement in mind when
considering and reviewing corporate, capital and discretionary
expenditures.
|
|
|
cc: John A. Marzulli , Jr.
|
|
Scott D. Petepiece
|
|
Shearman & Sterling LLP
|
|
599 Lexington Avenue
|
|
New York, New York l0022
|
|
|
Forward Looking Statements
This press release contains forward-looking statements that involve
risks and uncertainties and are subject to change based on various
factors. Many of these factors are beyond Rohm and Haas's ability to
control or predict. Actual results could vary materially from those
expressed or implied in the forward-looking statement. Further
information about these and other risks can be found in the company's
SEC 10-K filing of February 21, 2008, and updated in the 8-K filing on
June 6, 2008. This press release speaks only as of its date. Rohm and
Haas is under no duty to update this information.
Copies of all recent SEC filings, and additional information about
Rohm and Haas, are available through our web site: www.rohmhaas.com
About Rohm and Haas Company
Leading the way since 1909, Rohm and Haas is a global pioneer in the
creation and development of innovative technologies and solutions for
the specialty materials industry.
The company’s technologies are
found in a wide range of industries including: Building and
Construction, Electronics and Electronic Devices, Household Goods and
Personal Care, Packaging and Paper, Transportation, Pharmaceutical and
Medical, Water, Food and Food Related, and Industrial Process.
Innovative Rohm and Haas technologies and solutions help to improve life
every day, around the world. Based in Philadelphia, PA, the company
generated annual sales of approximately $8.9 billion in 2007. Visit www.rohmhaas.com
for more information. imagine the possibilities™