Gold Reserve Inc. (NYSE Alternext: GRZ) (TSX: GRZ) today sent the
following letter to shareholders urging shareholders not to tender their
shares into Rusoro Mining Ltd.’s (TSX-V: RML) ("Rusoro”) unsolicited
offer of December 15, 2008 (the "Offer”) to acquire all of the
outstanding shares and equity units of Gold Reserve in consideration for
three shares of Rusoro for each Gold Reserve share tendered under the
Offer.
The full text of the letter follows:
January 28, 2009
Dear Fellow Shareholder:
Gold Reserve’s Board of Directors has unanimously rejected Rusoro Mining
Ltd.’s ("Rusoro”) unsolicited offer of December 15, 2008 (the "Offer”)
to acquire Gold Reserve. Your Board is committed to ensuring that all
shareholders receive full value for their investment and believes that:
-
The Rusoro Offer does not represent a premium as it does not
provide shareholders adequate consideration for the fair value of Gold
Reserve’s assets and their relative contribution to the proposed
combined company.
-
Rusoro’s weak financial position would expose Gold Reserve
shareholders to increased risk.
-
Rusoro lacks the operational expertise necessary to maintain,
much less enhance, the value of the combined company.
On January 19, 2009, after more than 30 days of making its case to Gold
Reserve shareholders, Rusoro publicly admitted that less than 3% of
Gold Reserve’s outstanding shares had been tendered into its Offer.
We believe this sends a clear message to Rusoro – the Offer is
opportunistic, financially inadequate and significantly undervalues your
company. Despite the extremely low tender, Rusoro announced that it had
extended its bid expiry date to February 18, 2009. We are writing to
further highlight the deficiencies of Rusoro’s Offer and to urge you
again to REJECT the Offer and NOT TENDER your shares.
Rusoro’s Offer Undervalues Gold Reserve and Does Not Represent a
Premium
Rusoro is attempting to acquire Gold Reserve’s significant assets,
including our world-class Brisas Project and our significant cash
holdings, without paying you a premium for the underlying value of
your shares. Gold Reserve’s implied value per share, considering
Gold Reserve’s net cash, equipment and investment in Brisas, is more
than twice the current implied Offer price of C$1.95 (based on the
closing price of C$0.65 for Rusoro shares on the TSX-V on January 26,
2009). Under the terms contemplated in the Offer, Rusoro would
effectively pay nothing for Gold Reserve’s approximately 10.2
million ounces of proven and probable gold reserves and approximately
1.4 billion pounds of proven and probable copper reserves.
The respective contributions Gold Reserve and Rusoro would make to the
proposed combined company, the most significant of which are shown
below, demonstrate the failure of Rusoro’s assets, balance sheet and
reserves to provide fair value to Gold Reserve shareholders. Despite
Gold Reserve’s far greater contribution to the value of the combined
company, the Offer would provide Gold Reserve shareholders with a
mere 30% interest in the proposed combined company on a non-diluted
basis, with the potential for significant dilution in the next year or
two and exposure to increased financial and operational risk.
For example, Gold Reserve would contribute:
-
the construction-stage Brisas gold and copper project with:
-
proven and probable reserves of approximately 10.2 million ounces
of gold,
-
proven and probable reserves of approximately 1.4 billion pounds
of copper,
-
approximately US$230 million of investment in Brisas,
-
approximately US$109 million of cash and cash equivalents,
-
approximately US$47 million of deployable or saleable equipment,
-
the grass-roots Choco 5 exploration project, and
-
equity securities currently listed on the TSX and NYSE-Alternext.
On the other hand, Rusoro would contribute:
-
significant cash-flow concerns and long-term liquidity problems,
-
operational problems at Choco 10,
-
near term exhaustion of Isidora reserves,
-
an asset base that is largely encumbered by the Hambro/Endeavour Loan,
-
poorly disclosed related party transactions that have significantly
reduced Rusoro’s cash resources, and
-
delisting of the Gold Reserve shares from the NYSE Alternext and TSX
in exchange for a Canada-only listing on the junior Canadian TSX
Venture exchange.
Rusoro’s Weak Financial Position and Operational Performance Raise
Significant Concerns
Your Board believes that a transaction with Rusoro would expose Gold
Reserve shareholders to increased financial risk due to Rusoro’s
negative cash flow, working capital deficit and near term debt repayment
obligations.
We also have significant concerns about Rusoro’s
past delinquency with certain quarterly regulatory filings.
Consider
the following:
-
Since launching its hostile bid on December 15, 2008, Rusoro has
failed to directly address what we believe are financial deficiencies
outlined in its quarterly reports to shareholders, the most recent
being for the quarter ended September 30, 2008.
-
Rusoro has provided no update on its current cash position or any
meaningful guidance as to its liquidity outlook for 2009, and omitted
any discussion of this key issue in its last financial press release.
-
Substantially all of Rusoro’s assets are encumbered by the US$80
million Hambro/Endeavour Loan due in full in June 2010, yet Rusoro
lacks the cash flows necessary to meet this obligation.
-
A number of Rusoro’s quarterly filings with the Canadian securities
regulatory authorities over the last two years have been delinquent.
-
Rusoro has not publicly filed an audited annual financial report for
2008. Without this report, our shareholders cannot make an informed
assessment of Rusoro’s 2008 performance and its plans for 2009.
Based on Rusoro’s track record and its current operational problems,
your Board does not believe Rusoro has the operational expertise
necessary to maintain, much less enhance, the value of the proposed
combined company.
Rusoro has often failed to achieve its own forecasts in a variety of
categories including production rates, ore grades and metallurgical
recovery rates. Furthermore, Rusoro is operating at a loss despite
historically high gold prices.
On January 14, 2009, Rusoro announced "record gold production and record
low cash costs for Q4 2008,” in what we believe to be an effort to
deflect concerns over Rusoro’s historically poor operating results at
Choco 10. We believe the inclusion of high-grade ore from the
short-lived Isidora deposit may have skewed the results attributable to
the Choco 10 mine on a standalone basis, which has historically
remained cash flow negative.
Rusoro claims that an important factor in its Offer is its "full
exposure to gold price.” For the nine months ended September 30, 2008,
Rusoro’s gold was sold on average at a 26% discount to the international
spot price. In its January 14, 2009 announcement, Rusoro failed to
disclose the average sales price it realized on gold sales for the
fourth quarter 2008.
Your Board Questions Rusoro’s Purported "Established” Relationship
with the Venezuelan Government
Finally, while Rusoro implies that it is the Venezuelan government’s
"partner of choice” for mining opportunities in Venezuela, Rusoro itself
has confirmed that no agreement currently exists with the Venezuelan
government regarding the development and exploitation of Las Cristinas
and Brisas.
While Rusoro asserts that it is capable of obtaining the required
permits to develop and operate a mine in Venezuela, Rusoro itself has
never permitted and constructed a mine in Venezuela. The two mines
that Rusoro refers to as examples of its ability to "get things done” in
Venezuela were permitted and constructed by previous operators prior to
Rusoro acquiring them.
Your Board is Committed to Ensuring That Shareholders Receive Full
and Fair Value for Their Investment
To protect one of your company’s most valuable assets – its confidential
information – on December 31, 2008, Gold Reserve filed a motion in the
Ontario Superior Court of Justice seeking, among other things, to
restrain Rusoro from proceeding with its unsolicited offer because we
believe Rusoro had access to or benefited from the use of our
confidential information as a result of its relationship with Endeavour
Financial International Corporation.
Gold Reserve has cash, equipment, mining rights and other valuable
assets that belong to our shareholders, and we will vigorously seek to
ensure that our shareholders receive full value for those assets. We
believe Rusoro’s attempt to acquire our valuable investment in the
Brisas Project and our cash, without offering adequate consideration, is
inconsistent with our objective of enhancing shareholder value. We
believe that by continuing to execute on our long-term strategy, we can
realize significantly more value for our shareholders.
We urge you to REJECT Rusoro’s opportunistic Offer and NOT
TENDER your Gold Reserve shares into the Rusoro Offer. If you have
already tendered any of your Gold Reserve shares, we urge you to WITHDRAW
them immediately. Shareholders who have tendered Gold Reserve shares
into the Rusoro Offer and who wish to obtain advice or assistance in
withdrawing their Gold Reserve shares are urged to contact their broker
or Laurel Hill Advisory Group, the information agent retained by Gold
Reserve, at 1-888-295-4655.
On behalf of the Board, we thank you for your continued support.
Sincerely,
|
James H. Coleman Q.C.
|
|
|
|
|
Rockne J. Timm
|
|
Chairman of the Board of Directors
|
|
|
|
|
Chief Executive Officer and Director
|
Note to U.S. Investors
Information contained in this shareholder letter and in Gold
Reserve’s disclosure documents filed with securities regulatory
authorities, including the SEC, that contain descriptions of Gold
Reserve’s mineral deposits may not be comparable to similar information
made public by U.S. companies subject to the reporting and disclosure
requirements under the U.S. federal securities laws and the rules and
regulations thereunder. The terms "Mineral Reserve”, "Proven Mineral
Reserve” and "Probable Mineral Reserve” are Canadian mining terms as
defined in accordance with NI 43-101 under the guidelines set out in the
Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (the "CIM”)
Standards on Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves, adopted by the CIM
Council. These definitions differ from the definitions in the SEC
Industry Guide 7 under the Securities Act. The definitions of "proven”
and "probable” reserves used in NI 43-101 differ from the definitions in
SEC Industry Guide 7. We believe Gold Reserve has proven and probable
reserves pursuant to Industry Guide 7. In addition, the terms "mineral
resource”, "measured mineral resource”, "indicated mineral resource” and
"inferred mineral resource” are defined in and required to be disclosed
by NI 43-101. However, these terms are not defined terms under SEC
Industry Guide 7 and normally are not permitted to be used in reports
and registration statements filed with the SEC. Investors are cautioned
not to assume that any part or all of the mineral deposits in these
categories will ever be converted into reserves. "Inferred mineral
resources” have a great amount of uncertainty as to their existence, and
as to both their economic and legal feasibility. It cannot be assumed
that all or any part of an inferred mineral resource will ever be
upgraded to a higher category. Under Canadian rules, estimates of
inferred mineral resources may not form the basis of feasibility or
pre-feasibility studies, except in rare cases, and such estimates are
not part of SEC Industry Guide 7. NI 43-101 is a rule developed by the
Canadian Securities Administrators, which established standards for all
public disclosure an issuer makes of scientific and technical
information concerning mineral projects. Unless otherwise indicated, all
resource estimates of Gold Reserve contained in Gold Reserve’s
securities regulatory filings have been prepared in accordance with NI
43-101 and the CIM, Metallurgy and Petroleum Classification System.
Gold Reserve Inc. is a Canadian company, which holds the rights to the
Brisas gold/copper project and the Choco 5 gold exploration property in
Bolivar State, Venezuela.
Forward-Looking Statements
Certain statements included in this release may constitute
"forward-looking statements" within the meaning of the United States
Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, as amended, ("PSLRA"),
provided that statements made solely in connection with Rusoro's offer
are not subject to the safe harbor protections provided to
forward-looking statements under the PSLRA. Forward-looking statements
are necessarily based upon a number of estimates and assumptions that,
while considered reasonable by management at this time, are inherently
subject to significant business, economic and competitive uncertainties
and contingencies. We caution that such forward-looking statements
involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other risks that may
cause the actual financial results, performance, or achievements of Gold
Reserve to be materially different from our estimated future results,
performance, or achievements expressed or implied by those
forward-looking statements. Numerous factors could cause actual results
to differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements,
including without limitation, concentration of operations and assets in
Venezuela; corruption and uncertain legal enforcement; the outcome of
any potential proceedings under the Venezuelan legal system or before
arbitration tribunals as provided in investment treaties entered into
between Venezuela, Canada and other countries to determine the
compensation due to Gold Reserve in the event that Gold Reserve and the
Venezuelan government do not reach an agreement regarding construction
and operation of the Brisas project, or the Brisas project is
transferred to the Venezuelan government and the parties do not reach
agreement on compensation; requests for improper payments; regulatory,
political and economic risks associated with Venezuelan operations
(including changes in previously established laws, legal regimes, rules
or processes); the ability to obtain, maintain or re-acquire the
necessary permits or additional funding for the development of the
Brisas project; significant differences or changes in any key findings
or assumptions previously determined by us or our experts in conjunction
with our 2005 bankable feasibility study (as updated or modified from
time to time) due to actual results in our expected construction and
production at the Brisas project (including capital and operating cost
estimates); risk that actual mineral reserves may vary considerably from
estimates presently made; impact of currency, metal prices and metal
production volatility; fluctuations in energy prices; changes in
proposed development plans (including technology used); our dependence
upon the abilities and continued participation of certain key employees;
the prices, production levels and supply of and demand for gold and
copper produced or held by Gold Reserve or Rusoro; the potential
volatility of both Gold Reserve shares and Rusoro shares; the price and
value of the Gold Reserve notes; uncertainty as to the future value of
Rusoro, Gold Reserve or the combined company proposed by the Rusoro
offer; the prospects for exploration and development of projects by Gold
Reserve or Rusoro; whether or not an alternative transaction superior to
the Rusoro offer will emerge; and risks normally incident to the
operation and development of mining properties. This list is not
exhaustive of the factors that may affect any of Gold Reserve's
forward-looking statements. Investors are cautioned not to put undue
reliance on forward-looking statements. All subsequent written and oral
forward-looking statements attributable to Gold Reserve or persons
acting on its behalf are expressly qualified in their entirety by this
notice. Gold Reserve disclaims any intent or obligation to update
publicly forward-looking statements herein, whether as a result of new
information, future events or otherwise, subject to its disclosure
obligations under applicable rules promulgated by the U.S. Securities
and Exchange Commission ("SEC”).
In addition to being subject to a number of assumptions,
forward-looking statements in this release involve known and unknown
risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause actual results and
developments to be materially different from those expressed or implied
by such forward-looking statements, including the risks identified under
"Important Note for U.S. Investors Concerning Resource Calculations” as
well as the risks identified in the filings by Gold Reserve with the SEC
and Canadian provincial securities regulatory authorities, including
Gold Reserve’s annual information form for the year ended December 31,
2007, dated March 31, 2008, and Gold Reserve’s Annual Report on Form
40-F for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2007 filed with the SEC on
March 31, 2008.