What’s Hot: Dr Copper’s misdiagnosis

Something curious has happened in the copper market: copper futures curves have shifted into contango from a state of backwardation1. Backwardation is a sign of market tightness: people are willing to spend more on copper for immediate delivery rather than lock into a contract and wait a month at a lower price. As far as we can tell, the copper market is super-tight. A reversion to contango, we believe, doesn’t signify a loosening of the market and we believe backwardation will reign again soon. Curious contango Both CME COMEX2 and LME3 curves have made the transition. In fact, several base metals including lead, tin, and zinc have flipped to contango in recent weeks from backwardation. Investors in rolling futures strategies benefit from backwardation: as the futures prices approach spot through the passage of time (assuming curve shape does not change), its price should rise. Source: Bloomberg WisdomTree. Data from 25 November 2022 and 25 October 2022. USd/lb = cents per pound, USD/MT = Dollars per Tonne.Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value. Rolling futures have outperformed spot this year So far this year, the Bloomberg Commodity Industrial Metals Total Return Subindex has outpaced the Bloomberg Commodity Industrial Metals Spot Index: a product of backwardation in base metals. The erosion of backwardation could threaten this outcome. Source: Bloomberg WisdomTree. Data from 1/1/2022 to 30/11/2022. Total Return = Bloomberg Commodity Industrial Metals Total Return Subindex and Spot = Bloomberg Commodity Industrial Metals Spot Index.Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value. Inventory perilously low However, we believe contango will be short-lived as tightness remains. Firstly, copper inventory levels are very low. A small uptick in Shanghai inventory in the past month may not be sustainable if China starts to soften its excessive zero-COVID policies. Source: Bloomberg WisdomTree. Data from 22/10/2012 to 25/11/2022. Chicago Mercantile Exchange’s Commodity Exchange (COMEX), London Metal Exchange (LME), Shanghai Futures Exchange (SHFE).Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value. Further deficits to come Copper production forecasts are falling fast. The International Copper Study Group (ICSG)’s first forecast for 2022 copper balances (demand less supply), cast in October 2021, was for a sizeable surplus of 328 thousand tonnes. Its latest forecast (cast on 19 October 2022) is for a deficit of 328 thousand tonnes in 2022. Source: WisdomTree, International Copper Study Group (ICSG). ICSG’s latest forecast from 19 October 2022.Forecasts are not an indicator of future performance and any investments are subject to risks and uncertainties. Since the ICSG put these forecasts out, we have seen further signs of tightening in the market and we doubt that 2023 will be a surplus year. Codelco, the world’s biggest copper producer, will halve its refined copper sales to China in 2023, citing major production challenges at its Chuquicamata complex and closure of the Ventanas smelter, both in Chile. One of the main unions at BHP’s Escondida copper mine in Chile rejected a company proposal to address alleged contract and safety breaches on 24 November. Failure to reach an agreement could result in strikes in the coming days. Investors finally taking note Positioning in copper futures appears to have been weighed down by macro concerns. With central banks bent on killing inflation and risking a recession, many investors have ignored the fundamentals in copper and focused on potential for demand destruction. But the mood is shifting. Speculative positioning in copper has shifted to net long after being net short since March 2022. Source: Bloomberg WisdomTree. Data from 25/11/2017 to 25/11/2022. Chicago Mercantile Exchange’s Commodity Exchange (COMEX). Stdv = standard deviation.Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value. Conclusion Copper supply is tight and we expect a state of backwardation to return very soon. Sources1 Commodity ETPs are Exposed to Futures Contracts Not the Physical Spot. Why Does it Matter?2 Chicago Mercantile Exchange’s Commodity Exchange.3 London Metal Exchange Related blogs+ What's Hot: Industrial metal cyclicality is only skin-deep+ Recession may be a red herring for a market fuelled by a supercycle ]]>